Jump to Navigation

Sidewalk Accident/Premises Liability

A Brooklyn pharmacist tripped on a cracked and raised sidewalk in front of a two-family home, tearing the rotator cuff in his shoulder. The law provides that in cases where the adjacent property is a multiple dwelling of three families or less, the City of New York is responsible for injuries that result due to a defective sidewalk. However, in order to prosecute a case against the City of New York, you must prove that the City of New York had notice of the defective sidewalk. Our investigation revealed that the City of New York was never put on notice of the defective sidewalk as required by law. As such, our client was not able to file a claim against the City of New York for his injuries. Fortunately, for our client, the law also provides where the home, adjacent to a defective sidewalk, is greater than three families or is not used for exclusively for residential purposes or is not wholly or partially owner-occupied, the property owner is responsible for the injuries that are sustained because of a defective sidewalk. In this case, one apartment was being used by the homeowner and the other was rented out to a separate family. Our investigation revealed that the apartment which was rented out to a separate family was being used by one of the tenants for business purposes. We learned that the tenant designated himself as the registered agent for the service of legal papers for a number of corporations and had listed his apartment address with the Secretary of State for receiving legal documents on behalf of these corporations. In addition, we obtained copies of two Certificates of Incorporation from the Secretary of State where the tenant listed himself as an accounting office at his home address. We subpoenaed the tenant for a deposition and further learned that he prepares income tax and payroll tax returns at his residence on a limited basis. A Court will have to determine at some point in the very near future whether the homeowner's exemption under the statute is lost because of the tenant's accounting work. Supreme Court, Kings County, Birnbaum v. Haynes, Index No. 833/09

Contact Us Via Email

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Watch Our Video
Learn More About Fogellaw

Law Offices of Nussin S. Fogel
299 Broadway, Suite 620
New York, NY 10007

Phone: 646-736-2777
Toll Free: 888-391-8546
New York Law Office Map